TN budget 2012 reaction
There has been a good budget, looks like in TN this year. There has been a high allocation for agri!
While it is good to note that there has been a greater allocation for agriculture, thrust on sustainable farming (both ecologically and economically) would have helped.
see here!
That quote of mine about lack of anything organic is just one (big) lacuna in this budget..
there are others:
1/ The most strikingly absent feature is the Organic Mission fro the state. while many are states are announcing themselves to be going organic and releasing an organic mission for the state and announcing many proactive organic policies and programs to take the organic movement forward, it is sad that TN which has many pioneer organic farmers is missing the opportunity to lead from the front. This is especially important in today's scenario- on health as well as the fertilizer shortage/subsidy removal condition.
2/ The very talk of second Green revolution is very dangerous. It is well known fact that Green revolution focused only and 2 grains- rice and wheat and hence lost out in long term. Today most of the ills of farmers and farming (esp for the small and marginal ones) is due to the green revolution. The ecological impact too has been heavy because of GR. The much hyped 2nd GR in the east is already receiving flak in the eastern states of West Bengal, orissa, Assam etc and is being questioned and derided heavily.
3/ The agri Insurance is a very good and much needed scheme and increasing its coverage is great. But there are lots of issues on the ground level esp very operational and functional issues. These will have to be addressed to reap the benefit. So awareness programs as well as understanding the exact needs of the farmers needs to be planned. May be state level workshop with farmers, farmer leaders, civil society members, agri dept members and insurance experts need to converge. (SFA intends organising one such workshop)
4/ SRI- System of Rice Intensification is a good news. Hope it is taken up the organic way like in most other states in India. (actually SRI has grown beyond rice and shud be ideally called Syatem of roots Intensification)
5/ SPI- of pulses is also a welcome move.
6/ Marketing and storage facilities needs more attention and allocation. More plans should be around implementing them at block level.
7/ It is indeed welcome to see the mention about rehabilitation of tanks. If implemented, this would have been one of the greatest outcomes in this budget, considering the water crisis in the coming days.
8/ we should learn from the Cuba example. when in the 80s, US backed embargo was imposed, suddenly they were left without chemical fertilisers..and in crisis the country acted very boldly and prudently and went the sustainable, traditional and organic ways. Today it is the only 100% organic country in the world. needless to state that they are the most healthy society in the world - leading both in health and health care indices.
While it is good to note that there has been a greater allocation for agriculture, thrust on sustainable farming (both ecologically and economically) would have helped.
see here!
That quote of mine about lack of anything organic is just one (big) lacuna in this budget..
there are others:
1/ The most strikingly absent feature is the Organic Mission fro the state. while many are states are announcing themselves to be going organic and releasing an organic mission for the state and announcing many proactive organic policies and programs to take the organic movement forward, it is sad that TN which has many pioneer organic farmers is missing the opportunity to lead from the front. This is especially important in today's scenario- on health as well as the fertilizer shortage/subsidy removal condition.
2/ The very talk of second Green revolution is very dangerous. It is well known fact that Green revolution focused only and 2 grains- rice and wheat and hence lost out in long term. Today most of the ills of farmers and farming (esp for the small and marginal ones) is due to the green revolution. The ecological impact too has been heavy because of GR. The much hyped 2nd GR in the east is already receiving flak in the eastern states of West Bengal, orissa, Assam etc and is being questioned and derided heavily.
3/ The agri Insurance is a very good and much needed scheme and increasing its coverage is great. But there are lots of issues on the ground level esp very operational and functional issues. These will have to be addressed to reap the benefit. So awareness programs as well as understanding the exact needs of the farmers needs to be planned. May be state level workshop with farmers, farmer leaders, civil society members, agri dept members and insurance experts need to converge. (SFA intends organising one such workshop)
4/ SRI- System of Rice Intensification is a good news. Hope it is taken up the organic way like in most other states in India. (actually SRI has grown beyond rice and shud be ideally called Syatem of roots Intensification)
5/ SPI- of pulses is also a welcome move.
6/ Marketing and storage facilities needs more attention and allocation. More plans should be around implementing them at block level.
7/ It is indeed welcome to see the mention about rehabilitation of tanks. If implemented, this would have been one of the greatest outcomes in this budget, considering the water crisis in the coming days.
8/ we should learn from the Cuba example. when in the 80s, US backed embargo was imposed, suddenly they were left without chemical fertilisers..and in crisis the country acted very boldly and prudently and went the sustainable, traditional and organic ways. Today it is the only 100% organic country in the world. needless to state that they are the most healthy society in the world - leading both in health and health care indices.
4 Comments:
At March 27, 2012 10:57 PM, Pakka said…
Hi Ananthoo...I have to disagree. I would request you spend some time pondering on the questions below and revisit your conclusion on agri allocation.
a) Where is the money going to come for the allocation of spending ? Govt. of TN & GOI both spend more than they collect in terms of tax revenue ? This is deficit spending & it comes for printing money/Inflation. Immediate victims of inflation are the poor/marginal & elderly i.e. those with no or small income as their purchasing power is eroded. Note that India has spent & continues to spend a lot on agriculture as you are very well aware that has resulted in very little benefits to the farmers but large gains to big businesses, bureaucrats & politicians.
b) All this allocation will typically be wrongly utilized & there is likely be corruption & misuse.We know this from most govt spending & numerous scams.
c) This allocation will most likely increase bureaucracy i.e. more govt. employees rather than any real benefits to farmers. More big business friendly rules etc.,
The disaster we have in agri is due to constant intervention & various form of subsidies. When you have intervention it is very easy for big companies to hijack that by paying bureaucrats/politicians, hence big companies love regulation & subsidies they can cope with it better. They use it to keep competitors at bay, increase their market share & push their agenda.
Real learning from Cuba is that you don't need govt. spending in farming, leave people & farmers alone and they almost always do the right thing and in this case adapt sustainable agri & organic foods.
We Indians have to look at these things not just by the intentions what end results they likely produce. We have 60+ years of govt. spending & regulation record to look at. Good intentions are not the only thing required. In the olden days when India was growing all its food organically there was no govt. involvement. The king did not tell what to grow & how to grow there was no agri universities.
Warm Regards
Narasinga
http://narasinga-p.blogspot.com/
At March 31, 2012 9:49 AM, Ananthoo said…
:-) Narasinga..
u r right..but isnt that utopian? expecting govt to let the people free or not interfere..
also we cant now suddenly ask for no such mindles spending..so like when we vote, we seek for the worse among the worst, we just look at the worse of the worst budgets or policies..
such is our plight..
here, till lots of malaise and ridiculous policies are removed, we have to make do with what little relief happens and if that happens to farming sector and if it will help small farmers, one derives a small satisfaction..
thats all..
what to do:-(
At April 08, 2012 10:32 AM, agarwood investments said…
In the olden days when India was growing all its food organically there was no govt. involvement. The king did not tell what to grow & how to grow there was no agri universities.--In fairness, I do think there is some validity to this point. Its not realistic to think there will be no regulation, but the extreme levels of regulation can be negative.
At December 09, 2014 6:55 PM, oakleyses said…
burberry outlet online, ray ban sunglasses, coach purses, kate spade outlet online, christian louboutin shoes, louis vuitton outlet, louis vuitton, tory burch outlet online, nike free, coach outlet, longchamp outlet online, michael kors outlet, true religion, jordan shoes, prada handbags, polo ralph lauren outlet, coach outlet, tiffany jewelry, ray ban outlet, oakley sunglasses, true religion outlet, michael kors outlet online, louis vuitton outlet, cheap oakley sunglasses, kate spade outlet, christian louboutin, louis vuitton handbags, nike air max, nike outlet, longchamp handbags, polo ralph lauren, michael kors handbags, red bottom shoes, michael kors outlet store, burberry outlet online, oakley vault, chanel handbags, louis vuitton outlet online, longchamp outlet, michael kors outlet online, tiffany and co jewelry, gucci handbags, coach outlet store online, christian louboutin outlet, nike air max, michael kors outlet online, prada outlet
Post a Comment
<< Home